Kirkus Reviews on FIRST PERSON QUEER
Dec. 6th, 2007 01:30 am![[personal profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/user.png){kind=small}
desayunoencamaI'm very pleased, since it's a very positive review in one of the three big trade journals libraries use to order books from (PUBLISHERS WEEKLY, KIRKUS, and BOOKLIST).
They say:
Personal nonfiction accounts from every stripe in the rainbow and then some.
In their second anthology, Labonté and Schimel (The Future is Queer, 2006) have assembled a plethora of Canadian and American authors who share the “satisfaction of a realized sexual self,” a penchant for the pronoun “I” (though not all contributors prefer it in its upper case state) and little else. The collection winningly celebrates differences rooted in a variety of ways to the mutable boundaries of sexuality and gender. Nalo Hopkinson, who identifies herself as a “queer, poly woman,” begins by discussing her difficulties in filling out a questionnaire on women’s sexual fantasies; she found no boxes into which she “could have wedged my experience.” Gregory Woods worries that his “queer membership” has lapsed because a transurethral prostate resection at age 50 has rendered him impotent. “I am a suburban, middle-aged, neo-virgin, luxuriating in regret,” he movingly laments. “How queer is that?” Transgendered author and performance artist Kate Bornstein offers a touching, funny piece detailing the delicacy involved in describing to the “blue-haired” ladies at her mother’s funeral her relation to the deceased. Her identity was less of an issue for Mom, Bornstein writes: “I told her that one of her two sons was about to become a dyke. She preferred the word lesbian. ‘My son, the lesbian,’ she would tell her close friends, with a deep sigh and a smile on her lips.” Some selections are more successful than others, but individual snapshots matter less than the extraordinary queer panorama they collectively embody.
Whether read in a couple of sittings or savored essay by essay, this is an eye-opening vista on diversity.
They say:
Personal nonfiction accounts from every stripe in the rainbow and then some.
In their second anthology, Labonté and Schimel (The Future is Queer, 2006) have assembled a plethora of Canadian and American authors who share the “satisfaction of a realized sexual self,” a penchant for the pronoun “I” (though not all contributors prefer it in its upper case state) and little else. The collection winningly celebrates differences rooted in a variety of ways to the mutable boundaries of sexuality and gender. Nalo Hopkinson, who identifies herself as a “queer, poly woman,” begins by discussing her difficulties in filling out a questionnaire on women’s sexual fantasies; she found no boxes into which she “could have wedged my experience.” Gregory Woods worries that his “queer membership” has lapsed because a transurethral prostate resection at age 50 has rendered him impotent. “I am a suburban, middle-aged, neo-virgin, luxuriating in regret,” he movingly laments. “How queer is that?” Transgendered author and performance artist Kate Bornstein offers a touching, funny piece detailing the delicacy involved in describing to the “blue-haired” ladies at her mother’s funeral her relation to the deceased. Her identity was less of an issue for Mom, Bornstein writes: “I told her that one of her two sons was about to become a dyke. She preferred the word lesbian. ‘My son, the lesbian,’ she would tell her close friends, with a deep sigh and a smile on her lips.” Some selections are more successful than others, but individual snapshots matter less than the extraordinary queer panorama they collectively embody.
Whether read in a couple of sittings or savored essay by essay, this is an eye-opening vista on diversity.
![[identity profile]](https://www.dreamwidth.org/img/silk/identity/openid.png){kind=small}
no subject
Date: 2007-12-06 08:12 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2007-12-06 02:27 pm (UTC)